Sole Trader vs Company: When Is It Worth Making the Switch?

Your business might have started with just you and a few invoices. Now there are bigger jobs, higher profits and maybe staff to pay. But is your sole trader setup still the right fit?
In NZ, there's no set turnover figure or deadline for becoming a company. At My Two Cents, we generally start considering one when annual net profit approaches $80,000. That's a reason to review your options, not an automatic reason to switch. Your tax position, business risks and future plans all matter.
Why do most small businesses start out as sole traders?
Because it's simple, affordable and involves very little setup. You can trade under your own name, use your personal IRD number and register for an NZBN (New Zealand Business Number) if you want one.
You'll also need to consider when to register for GST depending on your turnover, but there's no company to register.
You can even employ staff as a sole trader. That's why we often recommend starting this way, unless there's a good reason to form a company from day one. If you're already the sales team, the admin team and the person making the coffee, keeping things simple has its perks.
Sole Trader vs Limited Company: What's the Difference in NZ?
The biggest difference is legal separation. As a sole trader, you are the business. You earn the income, own the assets and are personally responsible for business debts. You're taxed on the business's net profit.
A limited company is its own legal entity. The company earns the income, owns its assets and pays company tax. It can have multiple shareholders and generally offers some separation between business debts and personal assets, although that protection has limits.
The other big change? Company money belongs to the company, not automatically to you, even if you're its only shareholder. More on that shortly.
How much profit should you make before becoming a limited company?
There's no minimum profit required. But once a sole trader's annual net profit approaches $80,000, that's generally when we begin assessing whether a company could be beneficial.
Notice I mentioned net profit, not turnover. Turnover can look pretty impressive until the expenses turn up for their share. A business turning over $300,000 might keep considerably less after expenses.
We also look at whether profits are consistently increasing. One unusually good year or a big one-off contract doesn't necessarily justify changing your structure. What matters is where the business is heading, not just what happened last year.
Will switching from a sole trader to a company save you tax?
It can, but not automatically. Most NZ companies pay income tax at a flat rate of 28%, while sole traders pay individual income tax rates. Income above $78,100 is taxed at 33% and above $180,000 at 39%, with those higher rates applying only to income within those brackets.
That difference is worth looking at as profits rise. But it's not quite as simple as choosing the lowest percentage. If it were, I'd have a much shorter explanation for you.
How you pay yourself, any other income you earn and whether profits stay in the company all affect your overall tax position. We look at the full picture before recommending a change.
What other signs suggest it's time to review your business structure?
Profit isn't the only consideration. A company may be worth exploring if:
You're bringing someone into the business. A company can accommodate other shareholders or investors.
You're taking on bigger contracts or more risk. A different structure might better suit the work you're doing.
You're planning to sell or step back. A sole trader business can be harder to sell because it's tied to you personally, whereas a company can offer more straightforward options for transferring ownership or bringing in shareholders.
Your plans have changed. The business you run now may be very different from the one you started.
We also ask clients where they want their business to go and what they've got planned. After all, your tax return doesn't know you've got your eye on a second workshop and a new ute.
How does paying yourself change when you become a company?
As a sole trader, you're taxed on net profit, not how much you transfer into your personal account. With a company, the money belongs to the company, even if you're the only shareholder. Same owner, different rules for the bank account.
You can still pay yourself through a salary, dividends or properly recorded shareholder drawings. But if withdrawals aren't managed correctly, you could end up with an overdrawn shareholder current account.
Quite a name for a fairly simple situation: you've drawn more money from the company than has been credited to you, so the difference is recorded as money you owe back. Depending on how it's managed, that could mean additional tax or interest.
I've seen business owners operate through companies for years without having this difference properly explained. That's why we make a point of talking through how to pay yourself, not just how to set up a company.
We've covered this in more detail in our article on shareholder current accounts and what business owners need to know.
Does a limited company protect your personal assets?
Generally, yes. A company is legally separate from its owners, so personal assets usually have greater protection from business debts than they would under a sole trader structure.
But that protection isn't absolute. If you've personally guaranteed a company loan, you may still have to repay it. Directors can also be personally liable in certain circumstances if they breach their legal duties.
Running a company brings record-keeping responsibilities too. Beyond filing an annual return, you're required to maintain relevant shareholder records, financial information, meeting minutes and resolutions. The 'Limited' part doesn't extend to the paperwork, unfortunately.
These records can be audited, and failing to maintain them can result in penalties. Managing company compliance also involves ongoing work and costs, which we can take care of for clients, including acting as their address for service. This is part of the Companies Office compliance work we help clients manage.
Is it sometimes better to stay a sole trader?
Absolutely. If your business income suits your needs, you have no plans to add other owners or expand and your tax and risk position is appropriate, staying a sole trader can make perfect sense.
Maybe you're running a side business, working towards retirement or simply happy with the size of your business. If your business is doing exactly what you want it to, there's no need to add more chairs around the table.
We wouldn't recommend a company just because a business has been around for years. The right structure is the one that suits what you're trying to achieve.
What's involved in changing from a sole trader to a company?
Registering a company is just the first step. Think of it as getting the keys to your new business. There's still a bit of moving in to do.
You'll need to confirm the directors and shareholders, arrange the appropriate IRD, GST and employer registrations, open company bank accounts and set up separate accounting software.
You may also need to transfer business assets and liabilities such as equipment, vehicles and loans, and review existing contracts. There can be tax implications to those transfers, so the details matter.
Not everything transfers across, though. Outstanding invoices, supplier bills and tax obligations will often need to be settled under the original sole trader business before it's closed.
We often see avoidable hiccups with DIY changes, including incorrect GST settings, missing asset transfers and bank feeds starting on the wrong date. Where practical, we like to make the switch at the start of a GST period. A nice, tidy set of books makes us accountants very happy.
We can manage the registrations, accounting setup and relevant transfers, and guide you through opening the new company bank accounts.
What happens when a business outgrows its structure but nobody reviews it?
When a business's structure isn't reviewed as it grows, opportunities for better tax planning can be missed. We recently onboarded a client who'd operated as a sole trader for around 18 years without a proper review of his setup.
When we reviewed his financial statements and Xero records during onboarding, it became clear that moving to a company needed serious consideration straight away. His business had been generating substantial profits for several years, and there were other income sources to consider. Based on what we saw, a company structure should have been discussed much earlier.
That doesn't mean we can assume exactly how much tax he would have saved. His GST and tax returns had been taken care of, but the wider conversation about whether his business structure still suited him hadn't happened.
Call us a little nosy, but we like to know what's happening in your business beyond what's sitting in Xero. That's why we regularly review our clients' business structures alongside their financial performance. Year end is often when we spot opportunities, as we compare results with previous years and look at what's changed. What suited your business a few years ago might not be the best fit today.
How can My Two Cents help you decide what's right for your business?
We start with your latest financial statements or Xero records and a conversation about where you're heading. Are profits increasing? Are you thinking about bringing someone into the business, expanding or eventually selling? Or are you happy with things as they are?
If staying a sole trader makes sense, we'll say so. If a company looks worthwhile, we'll explain the tax, liability and admin implications and help manage the move, from registration through to the accounting setup and relevant transfers.
That's part of our business advisory work: looking at how your business is performing and whether your plans and structure still line up.
Not sure whether your business structure is still the right fit? Whether your next big business goal is hiring five people or finally taking Fridays off, get in touch with the My Two Cents team and let's make sure your business structure is working towards the same thing.

About the Author
Haley Reyners is the founder of My Two Cents Accounting & Advisory and a Certified ICNZB Master Bookkeeper® — one of the highest recognitions in New Zealand’s bookkeeping profession. With over 20 years of experience, she’s passionate about helping small business owners find clarity, confidence, and calm in their finances. Haley leads her team with personality and purpose, breaking down complex accounting talk into everyday language that makes sense.



